“There’s worse in” would be a really solid argument. Traditionally speaking, huffing and puffing past 300hr, 1000 rbi, and 2000 hits prob doesn’t scream HOF, even with the random MVP and Gold Glove. He’s got a solid reputation though and nowadays that counts for a lot, so I’d guess he’ll get in at some point. I don’t know his politics but hopefully he’s on the right side of the fence there