I really don’t think it’s an idiotic opinion. I like Berrios and I wouldn’t trash him but the opinion is hardly outlandish. You can do gymnastics whichever way you want. He’s a lifetime 4 ERA/FIP guy. That’s been mostly where he’s hovered before he kicked it up a notch last year. I personally think he’ll be closer to last years numbers again. However, I wouldn’t call someone an idiot for calling him inconsistent in his career to date. Or that he didn’t live up to possible front line rotation material that may have been the hope for some early on.
I know I targeted him in fantasy thinking he was going to take the next step and cut bait after awhile because of the inconsistency
His value has basically been in his durability. Like Marc Beuhrle, even if there is differences in how their numbers compute