I don't agree
A 50 FV prospect is worth something like $25M to $30M in NPV
Keller is owed 17, 18, 21 over the next 3 years
His 2026 and 2027 ZiPS are for 2.0 and 1.7 WAR; assume 1.4 for 2028
That's 5.1 WAR across 3 years for $56M which is about $11M per win
I don't think he's worth $30M in surplus value on that contract. His contract might actually be a fair free agent deal right now. Consider what guys like Kikuchi and Pivetta and Flaherty just got.
He's worth a premium that is equal to whatever it is worth this year to help with a playoff race + his surplus value remaining in 2025.
I'm not willing to burn Nimmala for this. I would burn certain other top 10 Jays prospects but probably not a top 100 mlb type.
I mean he's a perfectly cromulent replacement for Bassitt for 2026 on but that's not the priority here at the deadline. He doesn't move the "win the World Series" needle a whole lot does he? This is a RHP with a 95 Stuff+.