A .744 OPS may seem mediocre, but a 117 wRC+ isn't. I'm not in love with Swanson so I'm not going to the mat for him any more than this, but you guys are irrationally high on Tulo, and as dynasty assets I don't think they're anywhere close; Swanson is much more valuable. In a redraft, I would take Tulo, but this isn't that.