It's hard to say because Stroman doesn't really have much of a major league track record and I can't really ignore the fact that Quintana has been quite excellent for three straight seasons.
Do you look at other stats? You know, like the ones the league is based on.
Projected for an ERA around 3.70
K/BB under 3
Mediocre k numbers
Likely mediocre win totals
Knowing you, was probably a certain guy on the Mets. I find it quite fascinating that you appear to be drafting the same players you usually do despite consistently poor results.