Yeah, I think sometimes we underplay the mental aspect and it does seem like the Jays think it's a new market inefficiency. I mean, we are ahead of the curve here and I can't believe how much this FO is reviled by the idiot fans. What if there are a bunch of Justin Smoaks out there that simply need to tweak their mindset to unlock at least some of their potential?
I've been a big detractor of Grichuk's for a long time, especially when Nafro traded Greg Bird for him. However, hearing him speak so frankly on his weaknesses and how completely aware he is of the issues holding him back are really making me a big fan.
I think it goes back to what KingKat said earlier, the FO seems to believe that you can't teach batspeed, or footspeed or exit velo or the ability to barrel (which Grichuk does better than anyone other than Stanton) but you can teach basics like patience and proper mindset. A lot of players are pretty dumb and stubborn, so you find flawed (but very enticing) players with awareness and a good mindset and try to turn them into something great.
Lots of examples.
- Jose Bautista had s***** hitting advice for a long time - the predominant "all fields" approach. Opens his mind to attacking the ball early, becomes one of the best hitters in Blue Jay history
- Justin Turner, utility guy his whole career. Thought same hitting philosophy as Jose. Changes mindset, now attacks the ball out front, is one of the best 3B in baseball
- Josh Donaldson, on a mission of self improvement, goes outside his org for hitting advice, turns into a perrennial MVP contender.
- JD Martinez, pretty much the same as Bautista
- Edwin Encarnacion, similar
- Justin Smoak was a bit more of a next level example in that he simply needed to abandon the mindset where he needed to be that 30 homer 1B and try to mash every pitch when he didn't need to.
I'm really hopeful for Grichuk, tbh. He's got a pretty high 2 WAR floor, I think but I have a feeling he's going to crush that under the guidance of Shatkins.
And I thought I'd add here at the end of my long ass s***** post that I couldn't be happier with a manager like Gibby at the helm who keeps things loose and fun but also has an incredibly open mind about everything. Can you imagine a guy like LaRussa or Leyland in this scenario.
TL;DR: I f***ing love this front office, and i have huge hopes for Grichuk and Diaz too, for that matter. I actually think Diaz will be our SS or 2B by mid-May.
P.S. in that vein, I'd love to get our hands on Buxton. The the Twins are completely ruining him and he would be an amazing target. Idk what gets it done but the Twins are pretty stupid.