I posted on the MLB.tv support forum, and all they said was what I already knew, in that all that's available is the audio and condensed game. I couldn't find the condensed game, but I was able to find the gameday using the search feature on mlb.com. Here's a link to it. What's interesting is near the top of the page, there's a link for MLB.tv, but I'm sure you have to be a subscriber. I was able to load the game, so if you go through the gameday, you can apparently get games from 2009. If you are able to watch it, his at bat in the 2nd is around the 36 minute mark.