You're right i shouldn't be surprised, I was pissed when I wrote my post because on my commute I heard Blair keep repeating that Gibbons went with his gut on this, and even Atkins basically said it was Gibbons call lol. I was thinking that the GM should have stepped in and made the decision, but they did the right thing by presenting their side and have Gibbons make the final choice. Shapiro and Atkins seem like very, very level headed, intelligent, people persons.