So, since Steve Burtch did his Shutdown Index over at PPP, I expanded on his study by looking at adjusted overall Corsi. Like him, I adjusted for quality of teammates (TMCF/A20), quality of competition (OppCF/A20), and zone starts (he did DZFO% only, while I included NZFO% since it was also significant). Here are the top/bottom forwards and defencemen with this measure (I'm basically calling it dCorsi/20, which is the sum of SDI or dCA/20 and dCF/20). This is an accumulation of all seasons since 2007-08 and a minimum of 2000 minutes total:
Forwards:
Top 20:
1 WILLIAMS, JUSTIN
2 BERGERON, PATRICE
3 HALL, TAYLOR
4 SEDIN, DANIEL
5 KUNITZ, CHRIS
6 ZHERDEV, NIKOLAI
7 MOSS, DAVID
8 ELIAS, PATRIK
9 PONIKAROVSKY, ALEXEI
10 BERGENHEIM, SEAN
11 GETZLAF, RYAN
12 SEDIN, HENRIK
13 KENNEDY, TYLER
14 PACIORETTY, MAX
15 BOOTH, DAVID
16 HORNQVIST, PATRIC
17 HUNTER, TRENT
18 GRABOVSKI, MIKHAIL
19 EBERLE, JORDAN
20 PERRY, COREY
Bottom 20:
367 MARCHANT, TODD
368 ADAMS, CRAIG
369 MILLER, DREW
370 KOBASEW, CHUCK
371 STEWART, CHRIS
372 BOZAK, TYLER
373 BROWN, MIKE
374 PISANI, FERNANDO
375 MOREAU, ETHAN
376 MAYERS, JAMAL
377 DRURY, CHRIS
378 ORR, COLTON
379 FILPPULA, VALTTERI
380 SUTTER, BRANDON
381 BERTUZZI, TODD
382 GLASS, TANNER
383 DRAPER, KRIS
384 KORPIKOSKI, LAURI
385 HANDZUS, MICHAL
386 JOHANSSON, MARCUS
Defencemen:
1 CHARA, ZDENO
2 SUBBAN, P.K.
3 WEBER, SHEA
4 HEDMAN, VICTOR
5 SUTER, RYAN
6 VISNOVSKY, LUBOMIR
7 MARTIN, PAUL
8 LETANG, KRIS
9 BYFUGLIEN, DUSTIN
10 MEYER, FREDDY
11 HAMHUIS, DAN
12 COBURN, BRAYDON
13 BOYCHUK, JOHNNY
14 NIEDERMAYER, SCOTT
15 PIETRANGELO, ALEX
16 GOLIGOSKI, ALEX
17 DOUGHTY, DREW
18 GREEN, MIKE
19 RANGER, PAUL
20 PRONGER, CHRIS
Bottom 20:
212 ORPIK, BROOKS
213 ERSKINE, JOHN
214 FINGER, JEFF
215 EMINGER, STEVE
216 HANNAN, SCOTT
217 WEBER, MIKE
218 SKRASTINS, KARLIS
219 PECKHAM, THEO
220 MURRAY, DOUGLAS
221 SALVADOR, BRYCE
222 SOPEL, BRENT
223 EATON, MARK
224 MCKEE, JAY
225 SBISA, LUCA
226 WHITNEY, RYAN
227 MARA, PAUL
228 STUART, BRAD
229 JOHNSON, JACK
230 STRUDWICK, JASON
231 HAVELID, NICLAS