No, that would not be applying the same logic at all.
Firstly, Panik projects to be at least 1 win worse than Puig in 2019, after being 3.6 wins worse than Puig in the last 3 years
Secondly: Panik does only 1.5 things well, he makes contact at an elite rate and has decent plate discipline, unlike Puig who has a whole array of skills to fall back on.
Thirdly, the second point doesn't matter, because Panik has shown a demonstrable decline in power, something that he was only average at best at 4 years ago. So having a good contact rate doesn't mean jack when he has a barrell rate and exit velocity in the bottom 20th percentile in baseball.