Best battles for the all 21st century team? Utley vs Cano at 2B. Cabrera, ARod, Beltre and Pujols (Rolen and Votto are possibilities too...Chipper Jones if you are a terrible person) for the 3 spots of 1B, DH and 3B. You could cheat and put ARod at SS. OF of Trout, Bonds, Ichiro leaves out Beltran and I don't want to do that. McCann, Martin, Mauer or Molina at C. None of this includes more recent guys who deserve to be part of the conversation. Pitching for me is easier. Doc, Scherzer, Verlander, Kershaw and Greinke. Leaving CC out cause I'm racist...well more like he's just had so many more innings than everyone. He's my ironman but not my starter. Also leaving out King Felix cause you got to still be able to pitch into your 30s for my team. My bullpen is Mariano and no one else.
It's been a fun exercise glad you all played along