Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account
  • Blue Jays News & Analysis

    Why the Blue Jays Need To Bulk-Buy Pitching This Winter

    Toronto has plenty of arms on paper, but rumours are swirling about the team adding more.

    Sam Charles
    Image courtesy of Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images via Reuters Connect

    Blue Jays Video

    The Blue Jays thought they had enough pitching entering 2026. By season's end, injuries, inconsistency and underperformance had exposed just how fragile that depth really was.

    In a 1980 survey conducted by the Society for American Baseball Research, baseball experts estimated pitching accounted for roughly 60 percent of winning. Analytics have changed how teams measure success, but one principle remains unchanged: Teams can never have enough pitching.

    Very few teams can navigate an entire season without losing multiple pitchers to injury or performance issues. What looks like a strength in March can unravel quickly by August.

    That fear is already shaping much of the conversation surrounding Toronto's pitching staff heading into next season.

    At the moment, the projected rotation includes Dylan Cease, José Soriano, Trey Yesavage, Cody Ponce, and Spencer Arrighetti. On paper, it's a decent group but not a dominant one.

    Cease remains the clear ace and one of the premier pitchers in baseball. Even with the Steamer projections from FanGraphs showing some regression in 2027 from his peak seasons, he remains the type of arm capable of carrying a staff and matching up against any pitcher in the American League.

    The supporting crew behind him is where the question marks lie.

    Soriano clearly possesses frontline stuff but has yet to prove he can handle a full season as a top-of-the-rotation starter. If he takes 30 turns and throws 180 innings, the Jays look much deeper.

    Yesavage remains one of the organization's most important young pitchers, but the control issues that surfaced during portions of last season created some concern about whether he can immediately become the impact starter many envisioned after his dominant 2025 campaign.

    Arrighetti remains a pitcher scouts find intriguing, although his brief stint with Toronto did little to win over a skeptical fan base. Evaluators like his release point and ability to generate movement, but he clearly needs to improve his command and velocity.

    Ponce had his first season in Toronto derailed early by a freak injury. The Jays signed him to a club-friendly deal with the expectation that he could build on his success in Korea. He did strike out three in his only appearance in 2026. That appearance also included a walk, a hit and one earned run.

    Bowden Francis might come into play as 2027 unfolds. He has alternated between stretches of dominance and stretches of frustration. His overall numbers remain decent, including a 3.87 ERA over 200 major league innings, but injuries and inconsistency have prevented him from establishing himself as a reliable mid-rotation fixture. A team update from late September suggested his return is slated for some point during the 2027 season.

    Another wild card is José Berríos. For years, durability was one of his defining characteristics. Then injuries disrupted both the end of his 2025 and all of his 2026. The last team update indicated he might not return until late in the 2027 season.

    So, this group of starters might be good, or they might be underwhelming, and that doesn’t even take into account whether they all remain healthy.

    The group also doesn’t include a left-hander.

    That might leave an expanded opportunity for Ricky Tiedemann. For years, Tiedemann has been one of the most talented pitching prospects in baseball when healthy. Unfortunately, staying healthy has been the challenge. Last season, he finally earned a brief stop at the major league level.

    It might be early, but Cole Carlon, Toronto's top pick in 2026, gives the Jays another high-upside left-hander to consider. He was drafted out of college and a “best-case scenario” could allow a Yesavage trajectory. More likely, he is at least one, maybe two, seasons from a Jays uniform.

    The lack of left-handed depth may help explain why Toronto continues to be linked to some of the biggest pitching names available.

    That includes Tarik Skubal.

    The connection itself is not surprising. The Jays front office has not shied away from engaging with elite free agents, but they’ve only had limited success in landing them. George Springer and Cease might be the exceptions to that rule.

    More often than not, the Jays are used as a bargaining chip.

    With that said, the recently circulated photos featuring Skubal working out with Francis at the Apex Performance training facility in Arizona seemed to ignite added speculation.

    Skubal and Cease at the top of a rotation would be dominant, but the cost might be crippling. Skubal could command a long-term deal at around $45 million per season. Cease will bring in around $30 million next season, and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. makes more than $35 million. That would be a lot of money to spend on three roster spots.

    Realistically, the Jays have too many holes to fill, including strengthening the rotation, bullpen and offence, to justify signing a player like Skubal.

    If the team ultimately decides Skubal is too expensive or does not represent the best return on investment, the market still holds some intriguing alternatives.

    Freddy Peralta’s durability, strikeout ability and competitive edge would fit well in Toronto's rotation. Outlets like MLB Trade Rumors, ESPN, and NBC Sports project his market between $22-27 million annually on a four- to five-year deal.

    Michael King has transitioned from multi-inning weapon to frontline starter and is one of baseball's more impressive developments over the past several seasons. MLB Trade Rumors projects him to sign a four-year, $92 million contract, which would put him in a similar tier to Peralta.

    Sonny Gray offers reliability and experience despite advancing age. Just Baseball and NBC Sports project him for a shorter two-year commitment in the $27 - $32 million per year range. Gray declined his $30 million mutual option with the Red Sox at the end of last season.

    Kaima Taira represents a completely different path and would give Toronto access to high-end talent outside the traditional North American free agent market. MLB Trade Rumors projects his salary at $18 million annually over four years.

    Tyler Mahle remains intriguing if health concerns prove manageable. He is expected to fetch about $10 - 18 million a season for a short-term deal.

    Public projections place Trevor Rogers in the range of three to six years at roughly $17 - $23 million annually, depending on how teams view his durability and upside.

    Another option would be a reunion with Kevin Gausman. Gausman knows the organization, the city and the infrastructure. There would be virtually no adjustment period. Depending on contract demands and expected role, there could be a fit. Most outlets say his next contract would be one to three years at between $15 and 22 million.

    Chris Bassitt's experience and clubhouse presence were missed after his departure, and he remained a serviceable contributor with Baltimore, going 9-5 with a 4.41 ERA in 20 appearances. Rather than continuing to use him exclusively as a traditional starter, the Blue Jays could explore a multi-inning relief role. At a projected cost of $6-12 million, that could be a steal.

    Or they could bring back Max Scherzer.

    Regardless, the Jays will want to bulk buy pitching for next season.

    Within the organization, there are a few other pitchers just on the outside looking in. Nolan Perry represents the most realistic candidate to help the Blue Jays next season. The right-hander enjoyed a breakout 2026 campaign after recovering from Tommy John surgery.

    Across three levels, Perry posted a 2.50 ERA, struck out 117 batters in 82.2 innings and limited opponents to a .181 batting average. Just as impressive was his ability to move through the system. Perry advanced from Single A to High A and eventually Double A while maintaining his effectiveness. Perry's 1.02 WHIP demonstrated an ability not only to miss bats but also to limit traffic on the bases.

    Johnny King remains one of the most intriguing names. The left-hander split the 2026 season between High-A Vancouver and Double-A New Hampshire, posting a 5-4 record, a 3.16 ERA and 139 strikeouts across 105.1 innings. King struck out hitters at an elite rate while limiting opponents to a .210 batting average. His promotion to Double A before his 21st birthday reinforced the belief that the organization views him as one of its most promising pitching prospects. Like a lot of young pitchers, his big issue is command; 62 walks last season is not ideal.

    Will King be part of the Opening Day rotation? Probably not. But a few productive months in Buffalo could put him in position to debut by midseason.

    22-year-old Gage Stanifer is a fireballer who spent most of 2026 in Double A before earning a promotion to Triple-A Buffalo. He struck out 140 batters across 100.2 innings. His fastball can overpower hitters, and his strikeout rate continues to attract attention throughout the organization. Like King, he has command issues. Stanifer issued 66 walks and finished with a 4.83 ERA.

    Power arms frequently reach the majors through the bullpen first.

    Key parts of the bullpen are already locked up, but there are some openings. AL Reliever of the Year Louis Varland is a lock, as are Tyler Rogers, Mason Fluharty, Spencer Miles and Braydon Fisher.

    Brendon Little deserves credit for stabilizing himself as a useful bullpen piece. However, if Tiedemann returns healthy, the organization will eventually need to decide whether both pitchers can coexist in the bullpen or whether Tiedemann's future remains in the rotation.

    Jake Bloss and Chase Lee will make cases for bigger roles. Neither should be viewed as guaranteed impact contributors, but both are approaching the point where meaningful major league innings become realistic.

    Beyond them, the picture becomes murkier.

    José Rodríguez, John Klein, Chad Dallas and Brendan Cellucci all provide internal options.

    Like the rotation, the secondary players are the unknown. One or two more reliable additions could make a difference.

    Rumours are out there that suggest the Jays are at least part of conversations about Gregory Soto, David Bednar and Adrian Morejon. Market projections put Soto around $11 million next season, while Just Baseball, NBC Sports, and TSN project Bednar for a three-year commitment between $17 million and $20 million annually. Morejon could command even more. MLB Trade Rumors projects him for four years at $16 million per year ($64 million), while TSN pegs his ceiling as high as four years and $88 million ($22 million per season). More realistically, the Jays might target lefties Alex Vesia (for a short-term deal at $7 – 13 million per season) or A.J. Minter under similar terms.

    Brewers right-handed reliever Trevor Megill is in his final year of team control and becomes an unrestricted free agent in 2027-28. Would Milwaukee consider trading him in his last arbitration-eligible year? His projected salary is $8 million.

    Considering the challenges the Jays had last season when it came to generating runs, the smartest bet for success is stockpiling the best arms you can find to shut down opponents.

    Championship teams have reliable, dependable and resilient pitching staffs that bend but rarely break.

    Clearly, a team can never have enough pitching.

    The Jays don't necessarily need another ace. What they need is depth. Adding one reliable starter and one late-inning reliever would allow prospects such as Perry, King and Stanifer to arrive on their own timetable rather than being forced into major league roles before they're ready.

    Prioritizing where to reinforce the pitching staff will dictate how the Jays fare next season. By the end of the season, the rotation and bullpen might end up looking nothing like they did on Opening Day, and that might not be a bad thing if the Jays build out their options this offseason.


    Want to play the role of Blue Jays general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Blue Jays roster!

    Build Your 2027 Roster

    Follow Jays Centre For Toronto Blue Jays News & Analysis

    Think you could write an article like this one? We're looking for additional contributors, and we pay for all our content! Please click here, fill out the form, and someone will reply with more information.

    Recent Blue Jays Articles

    Recent Blue Jays Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...