I agree demoting him would be stupid and really isnt even an option, however, you can most certainly strike guys out at a high rate while still lacking consistency with locating your pitches, this is where luck does come into play. If you miss down and away, chances are it will not be a hard hit ball, you miss up in the zone, chances increase that it will be hit harder. From what I have noticed his mistakes have been up in the zone more. The same issue I noticed in Matt Boyd's start, his fastball was flat and up in the zone alot, it doesnt mean every single time its going to be hit hard, but the chances of it go up.