Gonna voice an unpopular opinion here, but locking up Donaldson to a high $, long term deal is just repeating the Tulo mistake all over again... If there is ANY truth to the Cardinals rumours, my ask is for (top prospect) P Alex Reyes & their current 3B Jedd Gyorko - if they don't balk, pull the trigger! We might have to add some int'l slot money or something, but it beats JD walking...
Then sign CF Lorenzo Cain to a 4-5yr deal, assuming he's got 3yrs as a starting OF left before taking his .300avg to the DH spot.
At this point I could honestly be okay with keeping Barney, but Goins or both of them needs to go. I would actually prefer a guy like Brett Lawrie as a cheaper, super-utility with a little better pop off the bench and a + defender.
Dump either Pearce or Morales for a song, need the roster spot more than the player.
Essentially we just need to stay afloat and compete for a couple years until Bichette/Vlad/Alford/Gurriel/Urena break in and stick.
C Russell Martin
1B Justin Smoak
2B Devon Travis
SS Troy Tulowitzky
3B Jedd Gyorko
LF Kevin Pillar
CF Lorenzo Cain
RF Teoscar Hernandez
DH Kendrys Morales or Steve Pearce
IF Lawrie/Barney, Refsnyder, Jansen/Torres, Tellez?
OF Carrera, Pompey?
SP Marcus Stroman
SP Aaron Sanchez
SP JA Happ
SP Marco Estrada
SP Alex Reyes
SP Joe Biagini
BP Tepera, Barnes, Rowley, Osuna, Leone, Mayza, Ramirez