Overrated might be a bit harsh but you definitely hit the nail on the head as to how most people view him. His bat has always left something to be desired, and during his bad stretches he's awful to watch as he just hacks away at every pitch no matter how far inside or outside in the dirt. It is scary and likely that as he keeps getting older he'll lose much of his value which is tied to his athleticism which makes him such a great defender. I wouldn't put a lot of stock into a single season of slightly worse defensive metrics, in which he still graded out quite superbly in comparison to his peers. The problem with a guy like Pillar is the league hasn't valued defense highly for a long time now, so you couldn't really move him at his peak value because the return wouldn't have justified it, he's a valuable guy to have on the team while he's young and athletic and his defense is great, but that all goes down south quickly when he stands on the wrong side of 30 and his defense sharply declines. Obviously you'd prefer a Trout or a Springer or a Blackmon over him but during his tenure with the team he's done a great job, much better than anyone could have hoped for from a 32nd round pick, with that said the team should be looking to replace him relatively soon, but with in-house options like Teoscar Hernandez and Anthony Alford there is some good potential without going the expensive route.