Well its much quicker to tell him in the thread to let me know what he is looking for as a return (prospect, roster player (pitcher/hitter), pick, and of what quality in any of those cases) than for me to PM him basically that exact question which involves me going into the PM system to do so.
But in the end, he didn't give any of that info, just asked what I would give up (giving me no info at all), so maybe you're right