Because 95% of those guys on HFboards think James Reimer is a product of Randy Carlyle's system. I went to the Leafs board a few days ago, and they're all singing the praises of Carlyle for leading the Leafs back into the playoffs. I mean sing his praises and even guys like Orr (Contract extension?) and McLaren, but bash the one guy that dragged this team into the playoffs and within one minute of defeating the powerhouse Bruins? Absolutely unbelievable.
"Hey kid, you had an unbelievable year and we probably wouldn't have come close to qualifying for the playoffs without your services, but we still don't trust you at all. Sorry for leaving you dry all those nights with Holzer and Kostka attempting to be competent NHL defenders, but at the end of the day you should have stopped those pucks in the third period of game 7. We lost because of you not making those saves, and not because we sat back for the last 10 minutes of the third, or because we failed to cover the points for the 300th game in a row. So yeah kid thanks for saving our asses on numerous occasions this season, but we trust Randy Carlyle and his great defensive system more than your goaltending".