IF he were to win a CY, I have absolutely no faith that he would still be good in 2016. He's just too inconsistent, plus he'll be another year older.
I was dead serious
How is that horrible? Bautista and Edwin are 2 of the top hitters in Baseball, and Martin and Donaldson are 2 of the top players in baseball with defense factored in. Reyes at 22million sucks but he'll still provide at least 2 WAR
Definitely would decline the option. Even if he were to win another CY this year, I would drop him after the season. He's just too old now and there are better options out there.
For 15mil? Lol no thanks.
With Buehrle, Dickey, and Romero off the books next year that should free up around 30 million. Enough to sign a legit frontline starter