Well, to be fair it was only 2 guys. I know you're down on it because Donaldson *could* carry an offense, but he could also miss half the year because of weak calves. Conversely, yeah, Berrios could just be a SP3 or he could be an ace like he was in the first half of 2018. I just really needed a 3B and given my pitching, especially with Paddack likely up next year, I felt like I'll still be a top 5 pitching team without Berrios.
Really, I think I've taken on much more risk then you did. You could have refused to deal him and then have him injured or ineffective next season, reducing your return even further.