You did, though, by comparing him to Cespedes. He's obviously no Cespedes. But he's a whole hell of a lot cheaper and he's probably a very good 4OF or a decent starting CF. If you read the report with those expectations, it seems pretty decent.
I've been thinking of this a LOT lately. Granted, entirely for the purposes of MLB the show.
Pitt: Reyes + cash
Tor: Bell + Hanson
Sfg: Reyes + cash
Tor: Mif prospect from Chc
Chc: Crick
Sea: Reyes
Tor: Miller/Franklin, ???
Det: Reyes
Tor: Suarez + Castellanos/Thompson/something