Vladimir Guerrero Jr. & Bo Bichette: The Faces Of The Blue Jays Franchise At A Crossroads?

With spring training just weeks away, all eyes will be on two of the Blue Jays' biggest stars: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette. For years, the duo have been the faces of the franchise, but as the 2025 season approaches, uncertainty looms over their long-term futures. An offseason filled with trade speculation and looming free agency has left fans wondering: Is this the beginning of the end for Toronto’s homegrown pair?

The Current State of Guerrero and Bichette
Since their debuts in 2019, Guerrero and Bichette have played pivotal roles in the Blue Jays’ success. Guerrero, an MVP runner-up in 2021, has proven to be one of the most powerful hitters in the game. Bichette, meanwhile, has been one of the most consistent shortstops in baseball, leading the American League in hits in both 2021 and 2022. However, recent seasons have brought inconsistencies—particularly for Bichette, who is coming off an injury-riddled 2024 season.

Despite their talent, the Blue Jays have yet to reach the World Series or even advance past the first round of the playoffs. As both players approach free agency, 2025 could be their final season in Blue Jays jerseys. Toronto fans are left wondering what decisions the front office will make.

Extension Talks or Future Trade Candidates?
The biggest decision is whether Toronto will extend Guerrero and Bichette or consider trading one (or both) before Opening Day or during the 2025 trade deadline. The team has engaged in extension talks with Bichette, reaching a three-year deal in 2023, but no long-term contract has been finalized. Speculation has only intensified that he could be on the trade block, with reports suggesting he may not envision his future in Toronto. Guerrero, meanwhile, has made it clear he wants to be a Blue Jay, yet no agreement has been made despite pleas from fans as the Jays chased high-caliber stars this offseason. Rumors are circulating that the Blue Jays and Guerrero are currently in contract extension talks, though Vlad set a deadline of the opening of spring training to complete said talks.

2025: A Defining Year
The 2025 season could ultimately decide the fates of Guerrero and Bichette in Toronto. They could command massive contracts if Guerrero can return to his MVP-caliber form and Bichette bounces back to his elite offensive production. However, if the Blue Jays underperform again, will they be forced to make franchise-altering decisions?