Will We Get a Bo Bichette Turnaround Moment This Season?

The 2025 Blue Jays had a season so magical we’re likely to talk about it for a generation. The home stretch and finish of the season is what will stick the most in our memories, while the start of the season might have been mostly forgotten if not for the team seeming to play the same song again this year. Through 36 games in 2025, the Jays were 16-20, a record identical to that of this year’s team six weeks into the season. Last year, they started May with a pair of wins and then dropped four in a row – again, identical to this season. The 2026 Jays have since dug themselves into an even deeper hole. The 2025 team returned to .500 on May 12; right now, Toronto sits at 18-23 heading into play on Tuesday night. 

The game and the at-bat many credited with turning the team around last season happened towards the end of May.

Going into their game on May 28, 2025, the Blue Jays held a 26-28 record and sat third in the AL East. Through eight innings, Toronto had left eight runners on base and was mired in a 0-0 draw with Texas (five Jays pitchers on a bullpen day combined to one-hit the Rangers and keep the game within reach). Ernie Clement led off the ninth inning with a single and was standing on second base with two outs in what looked like a carbon copy of so many failed innings before it. That was, of course, until Bo Bichette, called on as a pinch-hitter for the first time in his career, took an 0-1 pitch, sent it into the front row of the left field bleachers and single-handedly turned the Jays' season around.

That might seem like hyperbole, but Jesse Burrill wrote, “You could argue this was the point where everything started for this team.” Manager John Schneider touted that game as the one that flipped the switch and put the Jays on the path they ended up on. They would win nine of their next 10, get above .500 and put themselves in position to take over the division by July.

Now, with Bichette gone, where might we find that spark? Cory Sparks looked at how Ernie Clement is doing so far as a Bichette replacement, and while the power profiles are certainly different, Clement has had enough clutch hits that he could come up with the spark that ignites the season. Sam Charles talked about the roster ramifications of Addison Barger’s return, but with that return short-lived, maybe the season will turn around as quickly as Yohendrick Piñango did on his way to Buffalo, and maybe it will be one of the guys that keeps a roster spot that comes up with the magic. It’s early May, and it’s a long season, but if Toronto is going to turn the ship around, that work needs to start this month.

Of course, for the flip side, we don’t have to go any further back than the season before the magical ‘25. Through 36 games in 2024, the Jays sported a record of, you guessed it, 16-20. The turning point we’re looking for now never came for that team, and they never got above .500 and would sit fifth in the division from mid-June until game 162. Through some combination of parity, luck and schedule oddities, this year’s Jays team is only one game out of a Wild Card spot. On May 12, 2025, they were two back, and it was five games on the same date in 2024. We seem to be at a crossroads, and the path that is taken from here will make all the difference.