haven't you all learned from Smoakabello Barney&Goins if you are hitting you get benched or moved and if you are slumping you see more action , basically whatever has has the lowest % of working is the option Gibbons will put forth .
Ex. Dickey vs 1-2 Starters when he could only be matched vs 4-5 thus giving the team a better % to win.
I mean Dickey vs Kershaw that was just retarded , maybe a 10% chance to win that game.
Managers don't really have that much of an effect , but its like this guy dosen't even watch the games or look at any stats at all.