At first, Pennington was filling in nicely on defense. But the last few games, he looks like Reyes out there. With Tulo in the game today, the Jays win it because they turn that doubleplay where Penny threw wide.
And obviously offensively it is a huge downgrade. But I also think team morale and team confidence took a hit. Look at the way the team was playing after the trades, and now look. Tulo goes down and the team is just missing that extra little bit to push them over the top right now.