If he comes at that kind of dollar figure its pretty much a no brainer for me. As frustrating as he is to watch (with the exception of games where he's really on), he's a lock to be mostly healthy (aka no TJ), lock to get his innings in, shouldn't embarrass himself. I actually think the best aspect is giving opposing teams a really different look on the mound. Has anyone done a recent look on the knuckleball effect to see if its still looking like it's true?