Issues exist, but the game is not unplayable like the nonsense you were going on with, nor does the catcher do dives ever unless you are hitting the dive button. Again you guys are doing something wrong, are simply can;t use a controller properly...No one on OS sports, No reviewers nor anyone I know who plays online has ever had any of these issues nor has other guy in this thread. Saying there are issues sure, fielding could be more streamlined and bugs exists like every game, but saying it was terrible and unplayable is FUD. several being one, no one has had any of the other issues you had nor is saying it is unplayable, it is the highest rated sports franchise for a decade for a reason.
The issue the other poster had was him not being very good....he is not in the right spot to catch the ball in time. the show is a sim, not arcade baseball. It takes practice. Keep in mind fielding can be tailored in the show to play any way you wish.