The Next Ten:
11.) Adam Kloffenstein (short-season Vancouver)
Kloffenstein wasn’t all that different a draft prospect from his now org-mate Woods Richardson. He went a round later last summer, but commanded a bigger bonus to buy him out of his college commitment. He’s your more traditional “everything’s bigger in Texas” prep arm, a towering, physically mature 6’5” even while playing almost the entire year at age 18. But while Woods Richardson’s stuff popped in A-ball, Kloffenstein sat more low 90s—as opposed to the mid 90s he flashed his draft year—and the profile looked more strike-thrower than big stuff guy. As mentioned, he just turned 19, and it’s an ideal starter’s frame, but he might not be as safe a prep arm as we posited last year, which is still risky, but now riskier. —Jeffrey Paternostro
12.) Alejandro Kirk, C (High-A Dunedin)
Kirk will undoubtedly draw comparisons to Willians Astudillo for a handful of reasons. They are both international catchers with rather large, not jean-modeling frames, they rarely swing and miss, they get on base, and while the former had been overlooked for some time, that is not the case with Kirk anymore. It isn’t pretty sometimes. The bat speed doesn’t wow you, the power isn’t over the fence variety, he can’t run, and you wouldn’t be remiss if you didn’t like the overall athleticism. He just gets on base and hits and hits. The swing works. It is short and direct to the ball, he recognizes pitches well, and he doesn’t often force himself to swing at pitches out of the zone. The defense is better than you would imagine, as he blocks well, has tick-above-average arm strength, and has worked hard to improve his receiving. The overall outcome is a hit over power, on-base driven catcher. The risk here is that if he stops getting on-base there isn’t anything else to carry the load, but hey was this even a profile you would have banked on even just a few years ago? -Steve Givarz
13.) T.J. Zeuch, RHP (Toronto Blue Jays)
Zeuch is probably going to pitch in the majors for a long time. It’s a bushel of average or slightly-above pitches. He leads off with a sinker that typically sits 91-94, topping out at 95, and rides in with plus movement especially against righties. He’ll also show you a slider, a curve, and a change that all come in around average and flash higher. That stuff from a 6’7” pitcher with a classic delivery explains the “former first-round pick” part pretty easily. Yet the sum as a professional pitcher has, to date, been less than the sum of his parts. He just hasn’t fooled enough batters to strike anyone out despite being an advanced college pitcher with, what is on paper, pretty good stuff. He came up for September and was fine, used as both a back-end starter and the bulk guy behind an opener. He currently profiles as, well, pretty much that moving forward, with an asterisk denoting that tall pitchers with good stuff are more likely to suddenly put it together quite late in the development cycle.
14.) Kendall Williams, RHP (GCL Blue Jays)
In yesteryear’s baseball, a player like Williams probably gets drafted much higher, and ends up much higher on prospect lists. Who doesn’t like a 6-foot-6 right-hander who showed an above-average fastball and potential plus curveball? He was simply too much for young hitters in the complex given his size, angle, strike throwing, and stuff. The stuff is still inconsistent and the fastball dropped later in the year as he wore down, which was partially why he was still on the board at 52. Williams’ stuff should be ready for a full-season roster next year, but they will most likely keep him in extended to add strength to his wiry frame. —Steve Givarz
15.) Dasan Brown, OF (GCL Blue Jays)
A local kid whom the Jays drafted out of an Ontario high school, Brown displays a collection of loud tools. At the plate, he shows plus raw power. While his understanding of the zone is advanced for the age, his pitch recognition is undeveloped and, consequently, there are a lot of whiffs, especially against off-speed stuff. The swing itself comes with length. The arm and speed (which is plus to plus-plus) are sufficient for him to stick in center, though he may have to slide to a corner at physical maturity. There’s a major-league regular ceiling here, but his road to The Show will be longer than a Dream Theater song. —Kazuto Yamazaki
16.) Miguel Hiraldo, IF (rookie-level Bluefield)
Hiraldo, a 750k bonus baby out of the Dominican in 2017, has some thunder in his stick. The bat is going to have to carry the profile here, as he’s already playing a lot of second base, and his arm is likely to limit him there in the medium-to-long term, and the glove isn’t much more than average even at the keystone. There might be enough juice in the offensive profile to make it work though, as a potential average hit/solid-average power combo isn’t hard to see. And Hiraldo will spend all of next season as a 19-year-old. He’s definitely a potential breakout Blue Jays name for 2020. —Jeffrey Paternostro
17.) Otto Lopez, SS (Low-A Lansing)
The Jays seem to be grooming Lopez for a super utility role. This year most of his reps came at short, but he has played everywhere but first and catcher during his professional career. He is more than capable at short, but that position may be occupied in Toronto for a while. Lopez is a clean, smooth defender with good footwork, hands, and body control. At the plate he’s balanced and takes confident swings. He doesn’t strike out much thanks to quick hands, a simple, smooth swing, and a flat bat path that’s relatively short to the ball. He really doesn’t do anything poorly, but he’s not flashy and aside from the hit tool, he lacks any other loud aspect to his game. He’s never going to be a top prospect, but expect him to continue putting up strong batting averages until he cracks the majors. If things go well developmentally he may wind up an everyday player. There isn’t a lot of variance in his profile, so the floor is high here. —Keith Rader
18.) Riley Adams, C (Double-A New Hampshire)
A third-round pick in the 2017 draft, Adams conquered the Florida State League on his second go-around and was perfectly fine over a half-season-plus in New Hampshire. The profile behind the plate is a bit nondescript if I’m honest. He’s much taller and a bit narrower than your average catcher, but he’s reasonably quiet and athletic behind the dish, although he can snatch for the low strike. There’s a solid approach at the plate, but some stiffness to the swing that leads to swing-and-miss in the zone, although it gives him potential above-average pop as well. This was the kind of catcher that was a backup for a decade in the late-90s or early-00s. A passable glove that could run into a bomb for you. With the modern emphasis on receiving, Adams might have a tougher time getting major league per diems, but the profile is still solid backup catcher on balance. —Jeffrey Paternostro
19.) Patrick Murphy, RHP (Double-A New Hampshire)
The early part of Murphy’s pro career was routinely interrupted by injuries, but he was healthy and showing progress throughout 2018 and early 2019. That all came to a screeching halt last summer when his delivery was deemed illegal by the Major League Baseball Umpires Association, and he was sent back to the drawing board to craft a new set of mechanics that removed his key timing mechanism—a toe tap just before he began his drive toward the plate. Prior to that revelation, Murphy was consistently showing a plus fastball and plus curveball with potential for impact in the middle-to-late innings out of the bullpen. Now, after only throwing 20 innings in the season’s final three months following news of his illegal delivery, Murphy’s future is decidedly up in the air. Any challenges finding consistency with his new mechanics could hasten an already-likely move to the bullpen, and the timeline for his big league debut could be pushed back beyond 2020. —Mark Anderson
20.) Kevin Smith, SS (Double-A New Hampshire)
We ranked Smith in the top five of last year’s list based on his quick hands and above-average bat speed. We had hope for a good offensive outcome despite some continuing pitch recognition and approach issues, and he performed well at the A-ball levels. He proceeded to hit .209 with a 32 percent strikeout rate in Double-A in 2019, and then followed it up by performing about as well as your random American League pitcher in interleague at the plate in the Arizona Fall League. Worse, he looked just as lost as those numbers indicate. There’s enough of an excuse with a failed swing change that tried to tap into his raw—and help him deal better with the high fastballs that he’s always struggled against—to hope that some of this comes back around. And there’s always the utility fallback for a versatile player who can handle the 6, of course. But we really didn’t see or hear a single good thing on his bat out of the Eastern League or the Arizona Fall League all year.